Church of Planets Past

[Image: Photo courtesy of Andrea Tintori and Discovery News].

I love this story: the polished rock walls of a Catholic church in northern Italy have been found to contain the skull of a dinosaur. “The rock contains what appears to be a horizontal section of a dinosaur’s skull,” paleontologist Andrea Tintori explained to Discovery News. “The image looks like a CT scan, and clearly shows the cranium, the nasal cavities, and numerous teeth.”

The skull itself was hewn in two; “indeed,” we read, “Tintori found a second section of the same skull in another slab nearby.”

[Image: Photo courtesy of Andrea Tintori and Discovery News].

The rock itself—called Broccatello—comes from a fossil-rich quarry in southern Switzerland and dates back to the Jurassic. According to the book Fossil Crinoids, “The Broccatello (from brocade) was given its name by stone masons; this flaming, multicoloured ‘marble’ has been used in countless Italian and Swiss baroque and rococo churches”—implying, of course, that other fossil finds are waiting to be found in Alpine baroque churches. “In the quarries of Arzo, southern Switzerland,” the book continues, “crinoids [the fossilized bodies of ancient marine organisms] account for up to half of the bulk of the Broccatello, which is usually a few metres thick.”

In any case, to figure out exactly what kind of dinosaur it is, the rock slab might be removed from the church altogether for 3D imaging in a lab; a new piece of Broccatello rock, mined from southern Switzerland, could be use as its replacement.

The larger idea of discovering something historically new and even terrestrially unexpected in the rocks of a city, or in the walls of the buildings around you—as if the most important fossil site in current geology might someday be the rock walls of a ruined castle and not a cliff face or gorge—brings to mind recent books like Richard Fortey’s fantastic Earth: An Intimate History, with its geological introduction to sites like Central Park, Stories in Stone: Travels Through Urban Geology, and the Geologic City Reports (Parts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6) by Friends of the Pleistocene. These latter research files present New York City through the lens of its lumpen underpinnings, focusing on bedrock, mineral veins, and salt, not the city’s cultural districts or ethnic history.

But, of course, the H.P. Lovecraftian overtones of this story—a monstrous skull in a church wall—are too obvious not to mention: an easy scenario for imagining whole plots and storylines in which the ancient forms of an unknown species are discovered hidden in cathedral masonry, opening previously unimagined horizons of time and radically revising theories of the history of life on earth.

I just absolutely love the idea that a piece of architecture can become a site for paleontological research, framing an unlikely forensic study of the earth’s biological past.

9 thoughts on “Church of Planets Past”

  1. The irony – a building standing as a dedication to their god, the creator of all life, holding evidence of a contradictory theory of creation – evolution.

    this is great /

  2. (Yes, the Vatican likes evolution.)

    This is a pretty marvelous post, including all the book recommendations. Perhaps I'll finally get around to some Lovecraft 🙂

  3. Really interesting find! I'm going to find myself studying marble anywhere I see it now!
    And yes, I was raised Catholic and was always taught evolution. It's other sects of Christianity that deny evolution.

  4. Geoff,
    Thanks for mentioning my book Stories in Stone. I just did a little blog posting about this fossil. You might like the quote from one geologist who has studied this stone for more than 40 years. He said, "If this is the head of a dinosaur, I'll give up geology and eat my rock hammer."
    David B. Williams

  5. I'm not the least bit religious, but what is the irony in this? What if God created everything and set evolution in motion? I don't see how that contradicts anything others may believe about a Creator.

    Also, this post has a good example of the over-writing I see more and more of in this blog: The skull is "something historically new and even terrestrially unexpected in the rocks of a city". What does 'terrestrially unexpected' even mean? Or are you suggesting dinosaurs came from outer space? Otherwise everything on earth is terrestrial.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.